Therefore Having Gone

Therefore Having Gone

Monday, April 8, 2024

THE CUP ARGUMENT FOR PSA DOESN'T HOLD WATER

I have written elsewhere that I have never seen convincing Scriptural proof for the Penal Substitutionary Atonement theory's assertion that on the cross God poured out his righteous wrath on His Son so that God might remain just (by punishing sin appropriately) but also loving (by offering us forgiveness). 

A respected friend from across the aisle recently wrote, however, that he finds scriptural support for PSA in Jesus' reference to His impending death as a "cup" from God's hand in light of what a "cup" symbolized in the Old Testament. 

Many passages, the argument goes, use the cup as a metaphor for God's wrath. 

For example Psalm 75:8 -

In the hand of the Lord is a cup
full of foaming wine mixed with spices;
he pours it out, and all the wicked of the earth
drink it down to its very dregs.

On the surface, this looks like a convincing argument: The Lord does often hand out a steaming cup of wrath in the Old Testament. 

But there are problems.

1) Even if the majority of the Old Testament references to cups are negative, not ALL are. Most famously, King David wrote "my cup runneth over". Was it overflowing with God's wrath? Psalm 116 references the "cup of salvation". 

This illustrates a wider problem, then.

2) A cup is simply a vessel. It can hold something terrible, like wrath, or it can hold something refreshing, like blessings. The cup holds whatever God is handing to you. 

IF Jesus had said, "Father, if possible, take this cup OF YOUR WRATH from me", I would feel differently about this argument for PSA. But he never says what the cup is full of. Could it not be simply a cup of suffering?

But having said all that, one need look no further than the Gospel of Mark to see the cup argument for PSA fall apart completely. 

Remarkably, I saw a proponent of PSA writing for Ligonier Ministries cite Mark 10 as evidence of the cup Jesus drank being God's wrath. He quoted verses 35 to 38:

35 And James and John, the sons of Zebedee, came up to him and said to him, “Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask of you.” 36 And he said to them, “What do you want me to do for you?” 37 And they said to him, “Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your glory.” 38 Jesus said to them, “You do not know what you are asking. Are you able to drink the cup that I drink, or to be baptized with the baptism with which I am baptized?” 

Obviously, the implied answer to Jesus' question is "No" - it is His alone to drink the "cup of God's wrath". The author concludes that "cup" here necessarily "represents the cup of divine wrath that Jesus would drink on behalf of His people to save them from their sin." But notice the words "of divine wrath" do not appear in this passage. 

To his credit, the writer does acknowledge that the conversation did not end there. He mentions, but does not quote, verses 39 to 40:

39 And they said to him, “We are able.” And Jesus said to them, “The cup that I drink you will drink, and with the baptism with which I am baptized, you will be baptized, 40 but to sit at my right hand or at my left is not mine to grant, but it is for those for whom it has been prepared.”

Somehow, in the writer's mind, we are no longer talking about the cup of God's wrath. Instead, "Jesus was pointing to the fact that in a sense, they would share in the ordeal Christ was about to undergo in Jerusalem", i.e. they would suffer.

I agree with his conclusion - Jesus is saying the disciples will have a similar cup from God's hand, a cup of suffering. 

I am just not sure why Jesus' cup is assumed to be God's wrath in verse 38. If that is the proper reading of the first part of the passage, don't we have to be consistent and maintain that Jesus told His disciples in the second half that they would also drink the cup of God's wrath?

Saturday, April 6, 2024

FIRST DAYS AND LAST DAYS GO TOGETHER

I've been poking around in Hebrews lately. It's a fascinating book. I have never taken a deep dive into Hebrews, but I am feeling motivated to do so. 

I love how it starts:

In the past God spoke to our ancestors through the prophets at many times and in various ways, but in these last days he has spoken to us by his Son, whom he appointed heir of all things, and through whom also he made the universe. 

In this, Hebrews positions the New Testament happenings as the continuation and fulfillment of the Old Testament. 

N.T. Wright says, “We could perhaps look at Hebrews as a Christian introduction to the Old Testament. The letter points out that Israel’s scriptures were always looking ahead to something yet to come: a new covenant, a new type of priesthood, a new altar, a better sacrifice, a city to which the present Jerusalem would only be an advance signpost.” 

If we want to understand who God is and how He presents Reality, it behooves us as believers to get familiar with the great themes that are introduced in Genesis and then developed throughout the Old Testament.

Not only will this clarify for us what Scripture reveals about Life, Purpose, and Faith, it may also steel us against falling for more recently developed teachings which turn out to be distortions of the Truth. 


Friday, April 5, 2024

THE LOSS OF MYSTERY

I found this quote via Tim Ferris:

“I sometimes wonder whether conspiracy theories are an attempt to re-enchant the world in a distorted way. It’s like religion knocking on the door and trying to come back in a strange and distorted form. A sense of mystery beyond our own understanding of the world. If you ever talk to conspiracy theorists, that’s the sense you get from them.”  — Adam Curtis

I confess that I am not familiar with Adam Curtis. I don't know who he is but I think he may be onto something.

Across our culture in recent years I have sensed a growing sense of anxiety, cynicism and a bit of despair. 

And as the negativity rises, there seems to be a corresponding decline in awe and mystery. 

Is one side cause and the other effect? If I had to guess, I think we lost our sense of wonder first, and that precipitated a general malaise. If all the magic of being alive and aware of our surroundings disappears, we're left with nothing but the sadness and tragedies of this world. 

I don't know how the mystery was lost, but the Church must bear some blame. 

We were keepers of the miraculous and the supernatural. 

And now we mainly just gather together for an hour on Sunday mornings to sit and listen quietly. Is this what it looks like to be filled with the Holy Spirit?

It puts me in mind of a couple of other quotes; these from missionary Jim Elliot:

“We are so utterly ordinary, so commonplace, while we profess to know a Power the Twentieth Century does not reckon with.”

And

"Forgive me for being so ordinary while claiming to know so extraordinary a God.

Thursday, April 4, 2024

PERFECT

"Perfect" is one of those biblical words that deserves to be wrestled with. 

What does it mean that Jesus called us to "be perfect"? (Matt 5:48)

I have always disliked the "Christian" bumper sticker slogan "I'm not perfect, just forgiven". 

It fits right in with the all too common perception that a trip to the altar when you were eleven years old somehow functions as eternal fire insurance. And it doesn't really matter how you live out the rest of your days - Jesus paid for all your sins on the cross, past, present, and future.

Just frame that altar trip behind some glass and hang it on the wall. You won't really need it until death comes calling.

There’s really nothing in the New Testament that could justify such a view. 

If Americans read their Bibles more, I think this would be pretty obvious. 


Hebrews 10:14 - For by one sacrifice he has made perfect forever those who are being made holy.


Wednesday, April 3, 2024

DISSERTATION MILESTONE

After five months of saying, "I've got to finish this", today I did it - I finished the prospectus for my dissertation.

If you're not familiar with the terminology, the prospectus is simply the proposal for the topic I want to study and my approach to the project overall. It was 13 pages plus 3 pages of bibliography. 

It will need to be accepted by my academic advisor and I hear first drafts rarely are, so I anticipate needing to make some revisions before my project is formerly approved. The question is how extensive those revisions will be.

(I have no Plan B if the whole idea gets shot down, so I am praying my prospectus is well-received.)

Although this milestone represents several months of blowing past self-imposed deadlines, I feel encouraged because I have reached the starting line and I am excited about the work to come. That fact alone is worth celebrating. I don't know how I would be able to complete my degree work this next year if I didn't have enthusiasm for it.

As far as I can tell, this dissertation is the main reason the Lord opened this door of doctorate work through Wesley Biblical Seminary three years ago. 

I am eager now to walk through it and I am curious as to what waits on the other side.

Tuesday, April 2, 2024

CONVERSING WITH EMOTION

Charles Duhigg in Supercommunicators:

"Emotions impact every conversation, whether we realize it or not. Even when we don't acknowledge those feelings, they're still there - and when they are ignored, they're likely to become obstacles to connection." (p.161)

Can Duhigg get an "Amen!"? 

We are emotional creatures, not rational, and we communicate in ways that are emotional, not rational.

How many relationships are strained or broken primarily because people cannot express emotions on one side nor recognize unspoken emotions on the other?

Monday, April 1, 2024

EASTER WEEKEND 2024

What an incredible weekend - combining all the special worship of Holy Week with having all four kids together under our roof again. I loved every minute. 

I got to share from Scripture 4 separate times: At our own Maundy Thursday service, at the community Good Friday service, and then twice at Sardinia on Easter morning. And in between, I tried to spend as much time as possible with the kids.

Caleb and Hannah both arrived home late Thursday and then Samuel got home by lunchtime on Friday, so we had a solid 48 hours plus with everyone.

We put those hours to good use - eating out, enjoying springtime weather at a local park, and hiding Easter eggs. 





We discovered that Sugar is absolutely CRAZY about retrieving a frisbee.


It is so gratifying to see how much our kids love each other - even if that love is punctuated by squabbles and pestering each other at times. 

Easter breakfast at Sardinia Baptist was fantastic.



The kids helped their mom with the Easter egg hunt. Although some eggs were placed a bit out of reach for the gradeschoolers. 


They got to hide more eggs at Grandma Trudy's house later in the day - after the rain showers cleared away. 



And my kids always get a kick out of their cousins' kids. They get cuter and more fun as they get older. 


They enjoyed some alone time with Grandma after the little ones cleared out. And while I took a nap!


By evening, Samuel was headed back to school. Hannah and Caleb left after lunch today. Things are - sadly - back to normal tonight.

Yes, Melissa and I are very aware of how blessed we are!