Therefore Having Gone

Therefore Having Gone

Sunday, March 31, 2024

DISTORTIONS

Speaking of the Apostle Paul and his letters to the early church, Peter wrote the following:

15 Bear in mind that our Lord's patience means salvation, just as our dear brother Paul also wrote you with the wisdom that God gave him.

16 He writes the same way in all his letters, speaking in them of these matters. His letters contain some things that are hard to understand, which ignorant and unstable people distort, as they do the other Scriptures, to their own destruction.

17 Therefore, dear friends, since you have been forewarned, be on your guard so that you may not be carried away by the error of the lawless and fall from your secure position.

18 But grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. To him be glory both now and forever! Amen. (2 Peter 3)

The misinterpretation and distortion of Scripture is a perennial challenge for believers.

You can't believe every Bible teacher you hear. 

It is striking that the first misinterpretations of Paul's words got kicked off while he and Peter were still alive and writing!

Peter points out that neither promoting nor accepting distorted teaching is a matter of intelligence.

According to Peter, for those distorting Scripture, the problem is either ignorance or instability. (And ignorance is not the same as stupidity.)

And the problem on the receiving end is a lack of vigilance, leading to the familiar phenomenon of "being carried away" by an idea. (Again, neither is tied directly to intelligence.)

I did a search for "false teachers" and related terms in the Bible. At least two-thirds of the books of the New Testament address the issue. That points to a significant problem, doesn't it? 

Our response must be vigilance, as Peter taught. And that should include openness to the possibility that some theological "truth" we are holding to or promoting is a distortion of God's word. 

We are not immune, no matter how smart we think we are. 

Saturday, March 30, 2024

PSA'S COURTROOM DRAMA

One of the most famous analogies for Penal Substitutionary Atonement is the courtroom. 

Stephen Morrison* gives a brief and accurate summary of the analogy:

"God is a holy judge, and we are the guilty sinners. God’s justice demands payment, demands our death, and therefore God’s wrath is against us until payment is made. We deserve punishment, but we are unable to pay back God’s justice or appease His wrath. But Jesus Christ came out of love for us and died in our place; God punished Jesus instead of us, thus paying back the Father’s justice, satisfying His wrath, and saving us from hell.  God turned His back on Jesus Christ, and in forsaking Him, God now accepts us as His children. God’s wrath is appeased, God’s (retributive) justice is satisfied, and God can now accept us as His own. This is penal substitution: Jesus Christ is punished (penal) in our place (substitution)."

I have heard it preached this way: A guilty man (representing you and me) is brought into a courtroom. The judge (representing God) declares him guilty - because he is. Although the judge loves the man and desires to let him off, because of his justice, the judge cannot do it. Just at the moment of condemnation, the judge's son (representing Jesus) steps out of the shadows and says, "Father, *I* will gladly suffer this man's verdict on his behalf". The judge agrees, his son is punished in place of the man, and both love and justice are upheld. 

Whatever else the analogy illustrates, it brings to the foreground one of the biggest issues with PSA:

By its very claims, it divides the Trinity. (When you read Morrison's paragraph or my simplified version above, did it occur to you that "God" and "Jesus Christ" are not two different beings?) PSA begs the question: Is Jesus God or not?

In Penal Substitutionary Atonement, either Jesus is not really and fully God or, if He is, then God is punishing Himself. 

And if God is punishing Himself to satisfy His own Justice - How is that Justice exactly? 

AND if God is punishing Himself for the sins of humanity - Could that not be understood as just another way of saying that God absorbs the cost of our sins into Himself? (Which IS basically what I believe.) 


*Morrison doesn't believe in PSA, so there is a chance that a proponent of PSA might be able to accuse him of misrepresenting the theory, but I have certainly heard it preached this way. 


A LAST MINUTE FAVOR

There is so much packed into this brief story in Luke 23: 

39 One of the criminals who hung there heaped abuse on [Jesus]. “Are You not the Christ?” he said. “Save Yourself and us!”

40 But the other one rebuked him, saying, “Do you not even fear God, since you are under the same judgment? 41 We are punished justly, for we are receiving what our actions deserve. But this man has done nothing wrong.” 42 Then he said, “Jesus, remember me when You come into Your kingdom!”

43 And Jesus said to him, “Truly I tell you, today you will be with Me in Paradise.”

Imagine being a condemned criminal hanging on a cross, a few painful hours away from certain death, and looking at the guy nailed to the cross next to you, also condemned and dying, and saying, “I have a favor to ask once this is all over”! 

Something VERY unusual must be going through your mind … and heart.

From this very brief snippet of the interaction between Jesus and the two thieves, it is clear the second thief knew some things about Jesus. (Had he been among the crowds listening to Jesus’ preaching? Perhaps he was there picking people’s pockets!).

Here are 6 things the second thief knew about the Man hanging on the cross next to him:

  1. He knew His name was Jesus – Yeshua – “Yahweh Saves”
  2. He knew Jesus was innocent – in contrast to his own guilt. This was a confession of sorts – agreeing with God about his sinfulness.
  3. He knew Jesus was some sort of King – He brought up Jesus’ "kingdom".
  4. He believed Jesus would somehow – even at this late hour - come into His own Kingdom. 
  5. He had come to hope and believe that Jesus had Power – Why else would you ask him for a favor to follow the execution?
  6. He had come to conclude that God was good and MIGHT actually love him enough to want him in His presence!

Isn't it interesting that the second thief understood that Jesus had power, but may not use it to rescue them all from the crosses in that moment (like the first thief mockingly suggested)? He understood it to be a power that extended far beyond a last minute physical rescue. 

In my past life I was a high school English teacher. Teaching Shakespeare was one of my greatest joys. And my greatest terror. Much of the world's admiration for Shakespeare came from the fact that he was equally adept at writing tragedies as he was at comedies. 

In a tragedy, the end of the play is all death and destruction. The annihilation of all hope. 

In a comedy, the story first arcs toward that same conclusion (absolute disaster and despair) and then – miraculously – the best of all possible outcomes dawns, leaving the happiest of happy endings. 

On the cross, Jesus took what looked like a surefire tragedy and turned it into a divine comedy, the happiest of all happy endings. 

At least for the thief – and anyone else who recognizes Him for who He is. 

Both thieves knew that Jesus claimed to be the Messiah, the Savior. 

One believed it ... and woke up in paradise. 


Thursday, March 28, 2024

FAULTY PREMISES OF PSA

As far as I can tell, the logic behind Penal Substitutionary Atonement goes like this:

  1. God is just.
  2. Therefore, God cannot let sin go unpunished. 
  3. For a human to be forgiven means sin goes unpunished.
  4. To win our forgiveness, Jesus - though perfectly innocent - had to go to the cross and bear the punishment which we deserved.
  5. Now that God has meted out His punishment on His Son, He can forgive us.

Point #1 is obviously supported by Scripture, so PSA gets off to a good start.

But then the wheels come off immediately at Point #2. Can you show me where Scripture teaches that every sin must be punished by God or else his justice is compromised? (Instead, the Bible says that "mercy triumphs over judgment", James 2:13.)

Point #3 is true, but this is simply the definition of "forgiveness"! If the forgiven sin must still be punished - even vicariously as Point #4 would have it - then that offense was not in fact forgiven. 

It was repaid. 

If I say, "I forgive you for lying to me" and then turn around and punish you for lying to me, did I really forgive you? And how in the world would it make sense for me to punish someone else for your lie and then call that "justice"?

Points 4 and 5 are faulty conclusions because they are built on faulty premises. 

What does Scripture say?

Do you think this passage from Isaiah 30:18 sounds like the kind of hardcore justice which the God of PSA exhibits? -

Therefore the Lord waits to be gracious to you, and therefore he exalts himself to show mercy to you. For the Lord is a God of justice; blessed are all those who wait for him.

And what can PSA say in the light of Psalm 103:10-14? -

He does not deal with us according to our sins, nor repay us according to our iniquities. For as high as the heavens are above the earth, so great is his steadfast love toward those who fear him; as far as the east is from the west, so far does he remove our transgressions from us. As a father shows compassion to his children, so the Lord shows compassion to those who fear him. For he knows our frame; he remembers that we are dust.

It's fine to spend time hypothesizing about how the cross works, but any resulting theory needs to be grounded in Scripture and it needs to go no further than Scripture allows. 



“Love, not anger, brought Jesus to the cross. Golgotha came as a result of God’s great desire to forgive, not his reluctance.”

― Richard J. Foster

Wednesday, March 27, 2024

WHAT PSA GETS RIGHT

I have mentioned that I am not a fan of the sort of preaching which claims Jesus accomplished our reconciliation with God by suffering God's wrath while on the cross, the punishment which we ourselves deserved. This theory about how the crucifixion worked is called Penal Substitutionary Atonement. And I think it is a distortion of the Good News. 

Nevertheless, the foundation of PSA is solid. Here is what Penal Substitutionary Atonement gets right about the suffering and death of Christ:

1) The concept of Jesus as the "Lamb of God" (John the Baptist's first proclamation about Jesus is recorded in John 1:29 - "Behold, the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world!")

2) Jesus serving as a substitute for us (1 Peter 3:18 - "For Christ also suffered once for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit.")

3) Jesus bearing our sins on the cross (1 Peter 2:24 - "He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, that we might die to sin and live to righteousness. By his wounds you have been healed.")

But to jump from Jesus bearing our sins as the Lamb in our place to saying He suffered God's wrath is more philosophical than scriptural. I find it interesting that the handful of New Testament texts from which proponents of PSA draw their conclusion that the Father punished the Son on the cross are all from Paul. (And, as far as I can see, not one explicitly and plainly makes the claim of Jesus enduring God's wrath on the cross.)

If PSA is the reality behind the cross, why don't we see it in the Gospels? Why doesn't Jesus let His disciples know that He will be suffering the Father's wrath as He dies? In John's Gospel, we even get glimpses of the opposite: that God takes great pleasure in His Son's sacrifice. For instance, take the words John records from Jesus at the Last Supper describing his impending death: "Now is the Son of Man glorified and God is glorified in him." (13:31) 

THE central text used to bolster Penal Substitutionary Atonement, though, is Isaiah 53. And there are plenty of arguments back and forth about that text. All I know with certainty is that it does not explicitly say that God pours out wrath on Jesus.

And here's something interesting about Isaiah 53: It is the source of "By His wounds we are healed" which Peter cites in the passage above under point #3. But notice that when Peter cites this supposed PSA passage, his point looks more like the "Moral Influence" and "Christus Victor" theories. 

Look at the context of Peter's quotes from Isaiah. He's talking about how slaves should submit to their earthly masters, even if the master is cruel:

19 For it is commendable if someone bears up under the pain of unjust suffering because they are conscious of God. 20 But how is it to your credit if you receive a beating for doing wrong and endure it? But if you suffer for doing good and you endure it, this is commendable before God. 21 To this you were called, because Christ suffered for you, leaving you an example, that you should follow in his steps. 22 "He committed no sin, and no deceit was found in his mouth." 23 When they hurled their insults at him, he did not retaliate; when he suffered, he made no threats. Instead, he entrusted himself to him who judges justly. 24 "He himself bore our sins" in his body on the cross, so that we might die to sins and live for righteousness; "by his wounds you have been healed." 25 For "you were like sheep going astray," but now you have returned to the Shepherd and Overseer of your souls.

Peter here affirms some of the good foundations of Penal Substitutionary Atonement - Jesus bearing our sins and suffering in our place - without even a hint of Him being punished under the wrath of God in the process. 

Instead, Peter points to Jesus's death as being what has set believers free to return to the Shepherd (Christus Victor). And the suffering Jesus endured without retaliation serves as an example to us that we should "follow in His steps" (Moral Influence). 


Tuesday, March 26, 2024

DID JESUS SUFFER GOD'S WRATH ON THE CROSS?

Yesterday I gave some sample hymn lyrics and Scripture which support three longstanding theories of the Atonement - Moral Influence, Ransom, and Christus Victor. Personally, I consider all three to be sound and biblical frameworks for understanding how the cross of Christ brought reconciliation between God and Man. 

But none of those three are currently as fashionable in American Evangelical churches as a fourth theory, namely "Penal Substitutionary Atonement" (PSA).

Now that label might be unfamiliar to most Christians, but the concept is not. In fact, I feel like I need to tread lightly here because many think of PSA as essential to the gospel. (While I think of it as a distortion of the gospel.)

PSA says that in bearing our sins in His body, Jesus suffered the punishment from God's hand which we ourselves deserved for our sins. God's righteous wrath was poured out on His Son. This, then, is what satisfies God's justice and makes it possible for Him to forgive our sins. 

One of the best examples of this understanding of the crucifixion in lyric form is from a newer hymn, "In Christ Alone":

'Til on that cross as Jesus died
The wrath of God was satisfied
For every sin on Him was laid
Here in the death of Christ I live

For the longest time, I didn't question God's wrath being poured out on His Son for our sins. It sure sounded right to me. And maybe it sounds right to you. We've certainly heard it preached often enough, especially around Easter and in evangelistic sermons. 

But have you read it in Scripture? Or just heard it asserted and repeated?

Here's the tricky part of this discussion: I am in full agreement with the foundations of PSA: Jesus bearing our sins and acting as our substitute, His suffering on the cross, and certainly the fact that we deserve punishment for our sins. All of that IS Scriptural, no doubt about it.

The part that I find to be extrabiblical is God pouring out His wrath on Jesus to satisfy His own justice. THIS is the part - and it's the keystone of PSA - that I would challenge you to show me in the Bible. 

I don't see it. In fact, I find it to be a presupposition that contradicts clear Biblical teaching. 

But before we get into that, tomorrow I want to highlight those aspects of the Atonement which PSA gets right. 

[As a reminder, I am writing here merely my own thought process as I have wrestled with these ideas - If you disagree with me about PSA, then let's have a discussion!]



Monday, March 25, 2024

A SAMPLING OF THEORIES OF THE ATONEMENT

Believers are united in acknowledging that the death of Christ was necessary to bring reconciliation between God and humans. 

Most believers have likely never given much thought to various theories about HOW Christ's death on the cross actually accomplished that reconciliation. 

The CONTENTS of the various theories, though, are familiar to anyone in any church who pays attention to Scripture and sings along with the hymnal. That's because these theories are based on the Bible (for the most part!) and, thus, they find expression in the hymns we sing. 

Here are three example theories of the Atonement along with illustrations from a hymn and the Bible:

#1 The Ransom Theory

As found in "I Will Sing of My Redeemer":

Sing, O sing of my Redeemer, With His blood He purchased me.
On the cross He sealed my pardon, Paid the debt and made me free.

You'll notice the author, Philip Bliss, manages to avoid specifying to WHOM the payment was made. Was it the Devil? The Father? Some thing or somebody else?

This lack of specificity is not a weakness in Bliss' lyrics, though. In fact it is admirable. That's because Bliss goes no further than what Scripture does when using similar language about the crucifixion.

Take for example 1 Peter 1:18-19 ESV -

"Knowing that you were ransomed from the futile ways inherited from your forefathers, not with perishable things such as silver or gold, but with the precious blood of Christ, like that of a lamb without blemish or spot."

#2 Christus Victor

Here's the final verse of "Worship Christ, the Risen King":

We acclaim Your life, O Jesus; Now we sing Your victory.
Sin and hell may seek to seize us, But Your conquest keeps us free.
Stand in triumph, stand in triumph; Worship Christ, the risen King!

That's clearly the "Christus Victor" theory of the atonement - on the cross and through the resurrection, Jesus defeats sin and Satan and so wins our freedom from sin. 

Check out John 16:33 - “In the world you face persecution. But take courage; I have conquered the world!”


#3 The Moral Influence Theory

The final verse of "When I Survey the Wondrous Cross" is a good example of this theory which holds that Christ's life, death, and resurrection was mainly about providing us with an example to follow:

Were the whole realm of nature mine,
that were an offering far too small;
love so amazing, so divine,
demands my soul, my life, my all.

In Scripture we find verses like 1 Peter 2:21 - “For to this you were called, because Christ also suffered for you, leaving you an example, so that you should follow in his footsteps." 


So which of the theories is "right"?

Many theologians hold that the believer's best approach to understanding the mechanics behind the death of Christ is to hold a blend of the various theories. This is fitting because the language of Scripture employs at least these three. 

In holding a combination of various theories, we acknowledge the fact that much mystery surrounds the cross.

Fortunately we do not have to completely understand Jesus' death on the cross in order to benefit from the freedom, forgiveness, and reconciliation it brings.

C.S. Lewis writes in Mere Christianity:
"A man can eat his dinner without understanding exactly how food nourishes him. A man can accept what Christ has done without knowing how it works: indeed, he certainly would not know how it works until he has accepted it."